CARS.COM — Compact
SUVs continue to be a best-selling segment, and why not? They carry
plenty of people, cargo, pets, whatever you need. Because they're so
popular, Cars.com is now testing this category every year.
The 2016 Compact SUV Challenge
Results |
Multimedia Winners and Losers
This year's version is the first stab at our new Champions & Challengers approach: We pit the winner from the
last go-round
(the 2016 Honda CR-V; Honda declined to provide one for testing, so we
secured one from a car broker) and the segment sales leader (the Toyota
RAV4) against all of the compact SUVs that have been remodeled since our
last test in May 2015 (the Hyundai Tucson, Kia Sportage and Ford
Escape).
The judges for this Challenge were:
-
Joe Bruzek, senior road test editor
-
Jennifer Geiger, assistant managing editor, news
-
Bill Jackson, assistant managing editor, data
You can see how we conducted testing below the results. Here's how they all finished:
5 2016 Hyundai Tucson, 661 points
The
Verdict: "The Hyundai Tucson doesn't stink up the joint, although its
transmission comes close. Unfortunately, it doesn't do anything well
enough to recommend it over the other Challenge entrants," Jackson said.
What They Liked
Value proposition: As we often find with Hyundais,
"the Tucson offers a lot of value, as it's one of two SUVs that meets
our price cap and offers all-wheel drive," Jackson said. "Getting a
power liftgate, a blind spot monitoring system and all-wheel drive are
nice touches for the price," Bruzek added.
Punchy handling: "Its sporty nature makes the Tucson
the standout, fun-to-drive SUV in this test," Bruzek said. "It's the
athlete of the bunch," Geiger added. "Body lean is well-checked in
corners and maneuverability is excellent."
Ride, most of the time: "Its road isolation is
impressive," Geiger said. "Wind, road and engine noise are well-hushed."
But, she cautions, "skip the Sport model's sport-tuned suspension; the
ride is too firm, hopping over bumps with a brittle, jittery feel."
Getting around: "The dual-clutch transmission kicks
down well and offers a lot of passing power," Bruzek said. "Its potent
turbocharged 1.6-liter engine has punchiness the others lack."
And...: "Kids can be gross," Geiger noted from
experience, "but forgotten milk spills and gooey snack drool have met
their match with the Tucson's Yes Essentials stain- and odor-resistant
upholstery." "This sucker is roomy, both up front and in back," Jackson
said.
What They Didn't
Slow starts: The SUV that is so fun to drive at high
speeds suffers at low speeds. "The transmission's behavior had me
flashing back to driver's ed with its abrupt, lurchy shifts during
low-speed driving," Geiger said. Bruzek found it to be "jerky and
chattering," which made it "infuriating" to him, while Jackson found it
to be "a pain."
On the small screen: "The multimedia system is the
size of a deck of cards and the graphics don't look so hot," Jackson
said. Bruzek went even further: "It's a joke compared with the larger,
more robust screens offered at this price."
And...: "Cargo room in back is stingy compared with
the best in class," Geiger said. "The rock-hard front and backseat
cushioning is not very comfortable," Bruzek said. "The interior trim
over the glove box had some deep scuff marks," Jackson noted. "That
suggests that while the interior looks OK while it's new, it might not
hold up so well after a few months."
Research the 2016 Hyundai Tucson |
Search Inventory |
Car Seat Check
4 2016 Toyota RAV4, 691 points
The
Verdict: "The RAV4 is great," Bruzek said, "if your driving experience
isn't important to your consideration. Once you're behind the wheel,
it's immediately apparent there's room for improvement."
What They Liked
Storage galore: "The RAV4's cargo area is huge and
there are plenty of in-cabin cubbies, too," Geiger said, "my favorite of
which is a shelf above the glove box perfect for holding devices ... or
french fries." Jackson agreed about the shelf (although he did not
mention any snacks).
Cabin quality: "The high-quality interior has soft
materials in every nook and cranny, and attractive accent stitching to
boot," Bruzek said, and Geiger agreed.
Kid-friendly space: "The absolutely massive backseat
can fit your biggest buddies or provide separation between two feuding
kids," Bruzek noted. "The RAV4 gets straight A's for car-seat
installation with ample room and easy Latch connections," Geiger added.
And...: "I love that I can adjust the height of the
power liftgate opening from the driver's seat," Jackson said. And Bruzek
noted that "the 2016 version has made big improvements in quieting
engine, road and wind noise and highway speeds."
What They Didn't
That noise: "That's only because the previous
model was louder than a taxiway at O'Hare International Airport,"
Jackson said. "Its lack of road isolation got on my last nerve," Geiger
said.
Rough-rider: "Its road manners need work, with its
busy ride and numb, unnatural-feeling steering," Geiger said. "The
suspension crashes over bumps and feels cheap compared with the refined
ride of its competitors," Bruzek added.
No go: "The RAV4 is the pokiest of the bunch in the
passing lane," Bruzek said, and Jackson agreed. "It kind of dawdles
everywhere it goes," he said. "There's no driving pizzazz."
Behind the multimedia times: "The as-equipped midtier
multimedia system lacks smartphone integration like the top system and
neither of those systems offer Apple CarPlay or Android Auto," Bruzek
said. "It's a mixed bag," Geiger added. "It's a mess visually, with a
mix of knobs, panel buttons and a touch-screen, but there's no learning
curve when it comes to using it."
And...: "Yes, the rear seat reclines," Jackson said, "but reaching over your shoulder to make it recline isn't so fun."
Research the 2016 Toyota RAV4 |
Search Inventory |
Car Seat Check
3 2016 Honda CR-V, 694 points
The
Verdict: "The CR-V's roomy cabin and ample cargo room are appealing,"
Geiger said, "but its infuriating multimedia system and loud, slow
powertrain are deal-breakers."
What They Liked
Plenty of room: "The passenger and cargo room is big
enough to be borderline midsize-SUV territory," Bruzek said. "With the
most legroom of the bunch, rear passengers will have ample space,"
Geiger added.
Engine performance: "There's good power from the
CR-V," Jackson said, "especially when it comes to passing on the
highway." "For a continuously variable transmission, its operation is
nearly seamless, except for a slight lag from a start," Bruzek said.
Inventive features: "The CR-V's LaneWatch camera
system is a favorite that not only displays vehicles in the
passenger-side blind spot, but also cyclists and pedestrians," Geiger
said. "The backseat folds flat easily with the pull of a cargo-area
lever and its clever design makes it very flexible, able to carry
different-sized items," she added.
Value: "You get a lot for your money with the CR-V," Jackson said. "Our test model was one of the few with all-wheel drive."
And...: "The CR-V has tight steering, which makes you
feel connected to the road," Bruzek said. And "it has a high-quality
interior that not only looks good," Jackson said, "but it also looks
like it'd stand up to years of abuse."
What They Didn't
Multimedia nightmare: "The system is atrocious and
doesn't belong on any car in 2016," Jackson said. "It lacks conventional
knobs and dials," Bruzek pointed out, and Geiger found that "I've spent
a lot of time using Honda's multimedia system and it never gets
better."
Drivetrain issues: "The power takes its time spooling
up and the CVT complains loudly the whole time," Geiger said. "There's
an unpleasant sound there," Jackson said, "and I felt an occasional odd
vibration at extended idle."
Punishing ride: "The ride quality is firm and busy, and there's no reward in the handling to make up for it," Bruzek said.
And...: "It's time for new designers," Geiger said. "The CR-V gets chunkier and more awkward looking with each redesign."
Research the 2016 Honda CR-V |
Search Inventory |
Car Seat Check
2 2017 Kia Sportage, 753 points
The
Verdict: "The Sportage is the Goldilocks of this SUV class, with its
just-right blend of comfort, style and power," Geiger said.
What They Liked
Plenty of go: "With the Sportage's no-nonsense
powertrain, power is ample and delivery is smooth and prompt," Geiger
said. "The 2.4-liter's acceleration is welcomed among the sometimes
laggy turbocharged competition," Bruzek added.
Quite the ride: "No matter the surface, the Sportage
feels composed," Jackson said. "Only the Ford Escape offers a cabin
that's as hushed as the Sportage," he added. "It commendably balances a
comfortable ride with lively handling," Geiger said.
Multimedia bliss: "Using the straightforward
touch-screen system was a snap," Geiger said, "and connecting my phone
to Android Auto provided seamless navigation." Bruzek found it "painless
to use with tuning and volumes knobs, plus it has a large screen and
great Pandora integration."
And...: "Supple and comfortable seat cushioning is
covered with a stylish design and stain-resistant Yes Essentials
fabric," Bruzek noted.
What They Didn't
Value misses: "Others in this Challenge offered a
power liftgate but not our Sportage," Jackson pointed out. "A blind spot
monitoring system is available but not equipped," Bruzek said, "though
the Sportage came in $1,900 less than our price cap." Finally, Geiger
noted that "shoppers will likely have a hard time paying more than
$29,000 for an SUV without a push-button start."
The inside look: "With its bold face and chiseled
lines, the Sportage's exterior styling nails the sporty vibe but the
design-less black, plastic cabin is dull," Geiger said. "There's a lot
of hard plastic in the interior and a particular piece of interior trim
constantly hit my knee when I was driving," Jackson said.
Multimedia fail: "As an iPhone user, no Apple CarPlay
is a big miss," Bruzek said, "and if it had been offered, it would have
pegged the technology category's score." Given how close the Sportage
was to the winner, it might well have put it over the top.
And...: "The sporty curves and sloping roofline look
great," Geiger said, "but the sacrifice is rear visibility." "The big
2.4-liter engine is a little grainier sounding than the smoother
turbocharged engines," Bruzek said.
Research the 2017 Kia Sportage |
Search Inventory |
Car Seat Check
1 2017 Ford Escape, 755 points
The
Verdict: "The 2017 Escape is a great-driving small SUV, now with more
features for the money," Bruzek said, "but there's still a lot of the
old Escape's aged interior in it."
What They Liked
Infotainment system: This is a huge item because this
had been a Ford sticking point for years. "The previous MyFord Touch
system was likely a deal-breaker for shoppers but the Escape's new Sync 3
might actually be a deal-maker," Geiger said. "It's clean-looking and
easy to use." Bruzek praised its "ease of smartphone integration," and
Jackson said it was the "best multimedia system in the group; that it
has Apple CarPlay makes it even better. A clear win for Ford."
A comfortable, quiet ride: "The Escape has the best
driving dynamics and manages to feel responsive and composed over
bumps," Jackson said. "If you're looking for a compact SUV with a quiet
cabin, this one is at the top of its class." "Its refined, substantial
ride makes the Escape drive like a larger, more expensive SUV," Bruzek
added.
Help with the kids: "The backseat's exposed Latch anchors take the struggle out of car-seat installation," Geiger said.
And...: Bruzek liked "the numerous front storage areas
for phones and other pocket items," while Geiger liked how "the
powertrain is pleasant. Power builds steadily and smoothly, and never
feels strained."
What They Didn't
Interior style and quality: "There's a sea of hard
plastic and interior design that probably was futuristic when Ford first
went to it years ago," Jackson said, "but it could use a rethink." It's
"low on style and quality," Bruzek said, and Geiger said that "the
cabin's materials feel cheap and the overall design is uninspiring."
Ride issues: Although the other judges liked the
Escape's road manners, Geiger found them wanting. "Composure over bumps
is a problem," she said. "There's more hop and wiggle than an Easter
Bunny convention."
And...: "Ford said it improved interior noise levels
with this model but there's more work to do," Geiger said. "The engine
is loud and crude-sounding." "It has unimpressive fuel economy for a
high-tech engine with only front-wheel drive," Bruzek noted. "The rear
seats are hard, offer very little thigh support and there's not a lot of
backseat room," Jackson said.
Read more at https://www.cars.com/articles/whats-the-best-compact-suv-of-2016-1420684893542/#zxHltL0SGlyJdEYP.99
Read more at https://www.cars.com/articles/whats-the-best-compact-suv-of-2016-1420684893542/#zxHltL0SGlyJdEYP.99